What happens when your manager changes

Maintaining team engagement and productivity during manager changes is crucial. Clear communication, empathy and focus on continuity can help individual contributors (ICs) adapt to the change without losing momentum.

Let’s take a look at the opportunities and challenges brought about by manager changes:

Top 3 opportunities during manager changes:

1. Fresh perspectives: Manager changes bring in fresh perspectives, which can be beneficial. A new manager often introduces innovative ideas and approaches, leading to improved processes and skill development for ICs.
2. Growth and development: Change often spurs growth. A new manager might encourage ICs to step out of their comfort zones, providing new challenges and opportunities for professional development. This shift can enhance performance and skill-building, motivating ICs to push their boundaries.
3. Team cohesion: A well-managed transition can foster a renewed sense of purpose and alignment within the team. When ICs feel supported and see strong leadership continuity, it can actually strengthen collaboration, creating an opportunity to reset or refine team dynamics.

Top 3 challenges of manager changes:

1. Uncertainty and anxiety: Leadership changes can cause ICs to worry about job stability, role shifts or altered team dynamics. Without clear communication, uncertainty can lead to disengagement or even turnover.
2. Project continuity risks: With a change in leadership, ongoing projects may see hiccups. New managers need time to get up to speed, which could delay key deliverables or cause priority confusion.
3. Potential dips in motivation: Adjusting to a new manager’s style can be tricky. ICs who had strong relationships with their previous manager might struggle to build trust with the new one. This emotional adjustment can lead to a temporary drop in motivation, affecting performance.

Here’s a step-by-step guide to benefiting from manager changes:

1. Before the transition: Prepare ICs for change

Before a manager change is announced, it's crucial to prepare ICs by providing clear, transparent communication about what to expect. Early conversations help alleviate uncertainty and set the tone for a smooth transition. This preparation helps ICs feel informed, supported and ready for the shift.

1a. Communicate early + honestly

Get ahead of the news by sharing the manager change as soon as possible. Make sure your message is clear and concise. If the change is due to a promotion, restructuring or departure, explain why and how it aligns with the company's goals.

• Timing is critical: Avoid surprises. Share the news as soon as possible, but make sure the details are precise.
• Transparency is crucial: Be upfront about why the change is happening. Whether it’s a promotion, an organizational restructure or the manager leaving the company, ICs need context.
• Align with company values: Explain how the change relates to broader organizational goals or culture.

Pro tip: Announce the change in a team meeting to create transparency and follow that with 1:1 conversations to address personal concerns.

1b. Acknowledge emotions + reactions

ICs may experience anxiety, uncertainty or even excitement after hearing about a manager change. Acknowledge these reactions and provide space for them. Remind ICs that change, while sometimes challenging, can lead to new growth opportunities.

• Empathy first: Expect a range of reactions, from excitement to anxiety. Be empathetic to these emotions and provide a safe space for feedback.
• Normalize change: Remind ICs that change is inevitable in growing organizations, and while it might feel unsettling, it can also lead to new opportunities for learning and development.

1c. Plan for continuity

When preparing for the transition, make sure all ongoing projects and goals are well-documented. This minimizes disruption and keeps ICs focused on their work, not on potential unknowns.

2. During the transition: Create continuity + engagement

Help ICs feel confident that their job stability, goals and professional development will not be affected by the managerial change. Be proactive in reminding them of available resources, such as training or additional support during the transition.

2a. Explain the transition process

Outline what’s happening next. When is the outgoing manager leaving? When will the new one start? Will there be an interim manager? Clear answers to these questions will ease IC concerns.

• Provide reassurance: ICs will want to know how this impacts their role and day-to-day tasks. Reassure them that their job stability and performance goals remain unchanged.
• Training + development: Highlight any additional training or support ICs might receive during the transition — especially if the new manager is expected to introduce new methods or systems.

2b. Maintain project momentum

Work with outgoing and incoming managers to make sure projects continue without missing key milestones. A smooth handover is critical for keeping ICs motivated and engaged, and it shows that the company is invested in individual and collective success, even during times of change.

3. After the transition: Help ICs adapt

After the new manager is in place, focus on helping ICs adjust by fostering open communication and building trust. Encourage regular check-ins to address any concerns and ensure ICs feel supported. Providing clear guidance on expectations and maintaining continuity in development plans will keep the team engaged and productive.

3a. Introduce the new manager thoughtfully

First impressions matter. Create opportunities for ICs to meet their new manager in informal settings. Team lunches or casual 1:1s can foster connections before diving into work. Focus on how the new manager’s strengths align with team goals and the company culture.

• Create opportunities for connection: Introduce the new manager in a way that humanizes them. Arrange casual meet-and-greets or low-pressure 1:1s.
• Highlight strengths: When introducing the new manager, focus on their strengths and experience, especially how they align with the team’s goals and culture.
• Foster trust: Make sure the new manager is proactive in building trust with ICs. This can be done through authenticity and vulnerability while sharing their leadership philosophy, explaining their vision for the team and inviting feedback from ICs.

Pro tip: The new manager should outline their vision for the team and encourage feedback early on to build trust.

3b. Encourage open feedback

Let ICs know they can ask HR or leadership questions or concerns during and after the transition. Offering anonymous feedback options can help those who may not be comfortable speaking up directly.

4. Focus on retention: Keep ICs motivated

Maintaining IC motivation during a manager change is critical to retaining top talent. Reinforce their sense of stability by highlighting ongoing growth opportunities and ensuring their personal growth goals remain a priority. Regular communication and support will keep engagement high and help prevent turnover.

4a. Celebrate the outgoing manager

If the departing manager had a positive impact, recognize their contributions in front of the team. This offers closure and ensures ICs don’t feel like the person they respect is being swept under the rug.

4b. Prevent dips in engagement

A leadership change is a vulnerable time for team engagement. To keep ICs motivated and focused, help them feel supported and make sure they know their personal growth remains a priority. Offering additional resources, like professional development or mentoring, can reinforce their commitment and drive during and after the transition.

4c. Monitor team morale

Keep an eye on team morale. Regular pulse surveys or feedback loops can help you catch any signs of disengagement before they become more significant.

Closing thoughts

Manager transitions can be tricky, but with the right approach, you can help ICs navigate the change while maintaining high engagement, motivation and productivity. A smooth process ensures your team feels supported, valued and ready to succeed under new leadership.

• Empathy is non-negotiable: Leadership changes affect everyone differently. Being empathetic to the range of reactions shows your team that the company cares about their experiences.
• Consistency in leadership communication: Leaders at every level must be aligned when communicating changes. Mixed messages create confusion and uncertainty.
• Development shouldn’t stall: Make sure career development plans remain intact, even as leadership shifts. This reassures ICs that their growth remains a priority, keeping them engaged and committed.

‍